Just this spring, what is usually seen as a pro-business Supreme Court issued a ruling clearly on the side of workers. The case, Kasten v Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics Corp., addressed the question of protection for workers who file complaints against their employers. Smart business owners, with the right policies, will be able to turn this case to their advantage in keeping government investigators out.
The general rule has historically been that workers who report the illegal activities or illegal working conditions of their employers are protected from retaliation. This makes sense, we want those with inside knowledge of their employers fraud or illegal activities to feel they can come forward without risking their livelihood. But if the employee reported the problem internally, to an owner or supervisor instead of the government, there was always a question of whether protection applied. In other words, by trying to get the company to fix the problem in house, quietly and without a governmental investigation, did the employee lose the protections of the anti-retaliatory laws? The Court said no, employees who try to solve problems in house are still protected by the law (in this case, it was the Fair Labor Standards Act), even though the government was not involved. To qualify for protection against retaliation, the complaint can even be as simple as a verbal statement to a supervisor, it doesn't have to be in writing.
Since it's not unusual for less then stellar employees to have complained to a supervisor about working conditions or practices, this certainly creates an additional burden for the employer to comply with prior to terminating these under performing workers. It's not hard to image a scenario in which a company's failure to plan appropriately creates retaliation liability even when there was no provable case of an underlying violation. Of course, it also presents a huge opportunity for a proactive company to encourage internal self-reporting. As an owner, it's always preferable to learn about potential problems directly from your employees, rather then after they've reported your business to the governmental authorities.
The attorneys at Danziger Shapiro & Leavitt can assist you in framing an employment and self reporting policy designed to take advantage of this new holding, while planning for any potential claims. Our proactive approach also means we are frequently involved with our clients in operational audits to resolve many potential problems even before they arise. We've developed our own technological infrastructure for these reviews which allows us to provide these services on a surprisingly cost effective basis. Please call us today to discuss these and other issues affecting your company.